# Why Concrete Cracks, Sinks and Flakes

> Why does concrete crack, sink, heave or flake? Learn the common causes in Missouri, how to read each symptom, and what it means for repair or replacement.

Canonical page: https://midwesthardscapes.com/resources/why-concrete-fails/

Midwest Hardscapes (Midwest Hardscapes, LLC) is a concrete and hardscape contractor at 4025 Old Hwy 94 S, St. Charles, MO 63304, owned by Bryan Fennell, with over 33 years of experience in concrete. St. Charles concrete and hardscape contractor serving Greater St. Louis: driveways, patios, stamped concrete, pool decks, floors, curbs, outdoor living and commercial concrete, built by craftsmen who start with what goes under the slab. BBB A+ accredited since 2023; 4.8 stars from 31 Google reviews (November 2026). Phone (636) 206-8577.

From Bryan Fennell and the Midwest Hardscapes crew. Updated 2026-11-11.

Concrete fails for a short list of reasons, and most of them start below the surface or with water. Uneven support, a thin or missing base, inconsistent thickness, poor drainage, heavy loads, freeze-thaw cycles, tree roots and missing joints account for most of what we see on St. Louis driveways, patios and floors. Reading the symptom tells you a lot about the cause. Here is how to do it, and what it means for your slab.

## First, an Honest Note About Cracks

Concrete shrinks as it cures and moves as temperatures change, so some cracking is normal. No contractor can promise that concrete will not crack, heave or settle, and you should be cautious of anyone who does. The useful question is not whether a crack exists but what kind it is, why it formed, and whether it is getting worse.

A thin crack that follows a control joint is the concrete doing what it was designed to do. A crack that is widening, or one side sitting higher than the other, is telling you something is wrong underneath.

## Uneven Settlement

Settlement is the most common cause of sunken slabs. Soil under part of the slab compresses, washes out or was never firm to begin with, and the slab drops with it. Fill soil that was not compacted, a trench that was backfilled loosely, or a spot where water has been carrying soil away can all do it.

Older homes are a typical example. Many older slabs we replace show little or no compacted base. If a section has dropped, the question is whether the soil will keep moving or has stopped.

## Inadequate Base

Concrete needs even support from compacted base rock. Without it, the slab rests on whatever soil is there, and that soil holds water, swells, shrinks and settles. This is the cause behind a lot of replacement jobs. The slab itself was not bad; what was under it was.

Some contractors take shortcuts like skipping base compaction because the base is invisible once the slab is poured. We cover what a good base looks like in our guide to [what goes under concrete](https://midwesthardscapes.com/resources/what-goes-under-concrete/).

## Inconsistent Thickness

A slab that varies from thin to thick cracks at the thin spots. A pour that is a couple of inches in one place and much deeper in another has built-in weak points, and the crack pattern often shows exactly where. Consistent thickness across the whole pour is one of the simplest ways to avoid that.

Thickness should also match the use. We typically pour driveways and patios at a consistent 4 inches, but the right number depends on soil, use and loads, and it is not a universal requirement.

## Water and Poor Drainage

Water is the common thread in many failures. It softens the subgrade, washes soil out from under edges, collects in low spots and freezes. A slab that slopes toward the house, a downspout that dumps on the edge of a patio, or a yard that sheds runoff onto the driveway can all send water where it does damage.

Grading is how you manage it. Surfaces should drain away from the house and off the slab, not pool on it.

## Heavy Loads

Concrete handles weight well when it is supported evenly. Problems come when the load is heavier than what the slab was built for: delivery trucks, a dumpster, a trailer, equipment parked on a residential patio. Edges and corners are most vulnerable, because they have less support around them.

If a surface will carry more than passenger vehicles, tell your contractor up front. It can change the thickness, the reinforcement and the base.

## Freeze-Thaw Cycles and De-Icers

Missouri winters swing above and below freezing many times. Water that has soaked into the surface or gathered beneath the slab freezes, expands and thaws, over and over. That repeated cycle is what pushes slabs upward and flakes surfaces.

De-icing products make it worse. They add to the freeze-thaw stress on the surface, especially on newer concrete. Using sand for traction, shoveling early, using de-icers sparingly and never de-icing a slab in its first winter all help.

## Tree Roots

Roots grow toward moisture, and they can lift a slab from beneath or open cracks as they thicken. If a crack follows the line of a nearby tree, or one panel is rising near the trunk, roots are a likely suspect.

Roots are one of the cases where replacement alone may not solve it. We will tell you if the cause needs to be addressed before new concrete makes sense.

## Missing or Badly Placed Control Joints

Control joints create planned weak lines so cracking happens where you can live with it. When joints are missing, too far apart or in the wrong spots, the concrete finds its own path, and the cracks wander across the surface.

A good layout takes the shape and thickness of the pour into account. It is one of the details that separates a slab that ages well from one that does not.

## How to Read the Symptom

Use these as starting points, not diagnoses. Your slab is specific to your property.

- Sunken slab: usually settlement or washout beneath, often tied to base or drainage.
- Spider cracking (a web of fine cracks): often shrinkage at the surface, or a thin or poorly cured area.
- Heaving (a section pushed up): frost, tree roots or soil swelling underneath.
- Scaling (the top surface peeling in thin layers): often freeze-thaw stress, especially with de-icers.
- Spalling (larger pieces breaking off, sometimes exposing metal): often water reaching reinforcement or repeated freeze-thaw damage.

> A symptom points to a likely cause. Only a look at the slab and the site can confirm it.

## What to Do Next

Start by noting what you see and whether it is changing. Photos taken a few weeks apart help. Then read our [repair or replace guide](https://midwesthardscapes.com/resources/repair-or-replace-concrete/) to see where your problem likely falls. If it is a garage or basement floor, our [floor repair page](https://midwesthardscapes.com/concrete-floor-repair/) covers what is involved.

If your concrete is cracking, sinking or flaking, the cause usually matters more than the symptom. Bryan or the crew lead can look at your slab, tell you honestly what is happening, and say whether it needs repair, a section replaced or a full replacement. Estimates are free, and we would rather give you a straight answer than sell you the wrong fix.

## Frequently asked questions

### Why is my concrete driveway cracking?

Common causes are shrinkage, uneven settlement, thin spots, water and freeze-thaw. A thin crack along a joint is normal. A wide crack, or one with a height difference across it, points to something underneath. A site visit is the reliable way to tell.

### Is a crack in concrete always a problem?

No. Some cracking is normal as concrete cures and moves with temperature. Cracks that are widening, offset or letting water in deserve attention. We will tell you honestly whether yours is cosmetic or a sign of something bigger.

### What causes concrete to sink?

Usually the soil or base beneath it compresses, washes out or was never compacted. Water carrying soil away from under the edge is a frequent culprit. Whether the slab keeps sinking depends on whether the cause has stopped.

### What causes concrete to flake or scale?

Scaling is usually the surface peeling from freeze-thaw cycles, often made worse by de-icing products. It can also follow poor finishing or curing. It is mostly a surface problem, but it can signal moisture issues.

### Can tree roots really break a slab?

Yes. Roots can lift a panel or widen a crack as they grow. If cracking follows a tree, roots are worth checking before any new concrete is poured, or the problem may return.

### Can concrete be built so it will not crack?

No. Proper base, consistent thickness, reinforcement and control joints reduce the causes we can control and keep cracks tight and predictable. They do not make concrete crack-proof, and any promise otherwise is not honest.

### Do old concrete slabs fail because of age?

Age plays a part, but construction matters more. A slab built on loose or uncompacted soil settles and cracks much sooner than one on a compacted base. Properly built concrete can last for decades, and what shortens that is usually water, soil and loads.

## Contact

- Midwest Hardscapes, 4025 Old Hwy 94 S, St. Charles, MO 63304
- Phone: (636) 206-8577
- Free estimate: https://midwesthardscapes.com/contact-us/
